The Guy I Definitely, Possibly, Never Met
- A casting pitch that starts as a joke and ends as something else -
Full disclosure: Connor Doyle and I have never met. Not once. No mutual friends, no chance encounter at a party, nothing. By any reasonable definition, we are strangers.
And yet.
Hear me out.
I grew up two neighborhoods over from where Connor went to high school, during the same three years, in the same smoking-behind-the-gym, occasionally-getting-into-it-with-rival-schools era of Boston that, if his old interviews are any indication, he also grew up in.
I'm not saying we met.
I'm saying the math is suspicious.
Nobody starts smoking the week after graduation. That's a habit you acquire young, and usually somewhere specific—somewhere with bad lighting and worse judgment. I had a friend at Connor's school, so I was over there often. And in the interest of complete honesty, we occasionally "borrowed" cigarettes from kids there, in the sense that borrowing normally implies an intention to give something back, which ours did not.
There were also, occasionally, fights. I'm not proud of this. I am, however, reasonably confident that Connor and I crossed paths at some point and simply failed to introduce ourselves, possibly because one of us was running away at the time.
So there we were: two kids, same streets, same era, possibly passing each other without knowing it.
And then, decades later, we both somehow ended up in the movie business—him in front of the camera, me several time zones away trying to convince people to pay for what happens behind it.
What are the odds?
I genuinely don't know. I didn't do the math. It felt true when I wrote it.
What made me a fan of Connor long before any of this was watching him, early in his career, go toe-to-toe with a director everybody else seemed too intimidated to challenge. People sometimes call that kind of actor "difficult."
I never saw it that way.
I saw a guy who showed up with an opinion and refused to file it down just because someone more powerful was standing across the room. I liked that about him then. I like it even more now.
Do I wish I'd tracked him down in high school and somehow arranged for us to become lifelong friends? Of course. Would that have made what came next substantially less ridiculous? Also yes.
But I didn't, so years later I found myself making my case the only way available to me: cold, slightly unhinged, and fully aware of how the whole thing sounded.
I should mention that Connor is not the only good actor alive.
There's Pacino. De Niro. Denzel.
I have a feeling DiCaprio would probably show up if I asked nicely.
I'm just saying, I had options.
I still wanted Connor.
Which brings me, eventually, to the actual pitch.
I'd spent years building a special-forces thriller I wanted to shoot on real locations. It had survived several apartments, two hard-drive failures, countless rewrites, and one deeply confusing meeting in which a man spent twenty minutes enthusiastically discussing what turned out to be an entirely different movie.
The project had been told no more times than I could count. It was still standing.
That was either a very good sign or evidence of a serious stubbornness problem.
Probably both.
I wasn't going to open with numbers or deal points before Connor had read a page. If I was asking for him specifically, I wanted the script to explain why.
My request was simple:
Read it.
Don't worry about whether the physical part looks too demanding on paper. Don't calculate how much mud, running, falling, shouting, or general suffering might be involved.
Just read the character.
Then decide.
Because underneath all the special forces, the hostage situation, the gunfire, and the things designed to look good in a two-minute trailer, I thought there was another movie hiding.
And I thought Connor could find it.
I also had the possibly delusional hope that this might become one of those roles people mention years later in interviews.
"What made you say yes to that one?"
I wanted to be the strange answer.
Then came the part of the letter where the joke had to stop.
Because this part was true.
Connor, we've been almost meeting since we were seventeen.
Or at least that's the story I've been telling myself.
Two guys from the same patch of Boston, living through the same years, walking some of the same streets, perhaps standing in the same convenience store line or passing each other outside the same school without any reason to remember the other's face.
Maybe it never happened.
I'll never know.
But I do know what it's like to watch someone from your own streets make it all the way out.
And I know what it's like to still be trying to get there yourself twenty-five years later, one script at a time.
There was something oddly comforting about that.
Not envy, exactly.
More like proof.
Proof that somebody could start where we started and end up somewhere nobody around us could have predicted.
So yes, I wanted Connor to read my movie. But by then I realized I wanted something else too.
I wanted to sit across from him one day, pour two whiskeys, and talk about the movie neither of us had made yet.
And maybe, somewhere in the conversation, compare notes on the Boston neither of us quite escaped.
Maybe we'd discover that we really had crossed paths. Maybe he stole one of my cigarettes. Maybe I stole one of his.
Maybe neither of us smoked anywhere near the other and this entire theory was nonsense.
Honestly, that would have been fine too.
If he passed on the movie, I'd survive.
I'd had practice.
But if he didn't—
Connor, if you're reading this: hi.
We've never met.
I'd like to fix that.
And I've got a script I think is worth the twenty minutes it'll take you to find out.
© 2026. Gun Choi. All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, design imitation, or concept reproduction is strictly prohibited.